blog




  • Essay / McCarthy versus Mcewan: minimalist and excessive narrative styles

    British novelist Ian McEwan's masterpiece, Atonement, can be aptly compared to American writer Cormac McCarthy's novel, No Country for Old Men, with the common theme of intense experience: its opportunities and ramifications. In contrast, each author chooses to present the motif using a completely opposite method in order to achieve different types of effects, both for the readership and for the development of the characters in the novel. Opposing narrative styles incorporate minimalism – in McCarthy's case – while McEwan takes a textured, multi-layered approach. Each technique hints at a broader perspective, drawing readers further into the story worlds that both authors have brilliantly crafted. The correlation between cinema and literature is emphasized in the comparison of these ingenious 21st century novels, as Hollywood depictions also exhibit a certain degree of variance in their attempt to extend the equivalents of literary diversity and complexity. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get an original essay The novel Atonement by Ian McEwan illustrates the multi-dimensional storytelling frameworks of literary technique to further draw the readership into the work. This kaleidoscopic structure of fiction and nonfiction, fabrication and reality, dishonesty and authenticity is closely tied to the development of several key characters within the novel's pages. The first section of the work shines with some touches of fiction – taken from the work of a young playwright – a strong tactic that lays the foundation for a deeper metafictional representation. The atonement, carefully planned and meticulously organized, emphasizes the theme of opposites in multiple facets because it encompasses the exchange between several important factors. Composed in a traditional third-person narrative, McEwan dances in and out of the heads of his characters, from members of the Tallis family to the friends at the heart of the developing plot. This narrative style merges a tedious approach to character development and maturation, a tactical imperative in the specific case of Briony Tallis since the novel covers sixty years of her life. McEwan achieves this successfully by exploring the thoughts and desires of his central characters. Amid careful attention to accuracy, the author incorporates meticulous imagery although this absorbed writing style does not distract from the main themes of the novel. McEwan incorporates such careful prose that effectively balances keen attention to detail with a meticulous approach to the development of his characters. Moreover, it is the tiny details, sounds and sensations that lead to the climax of the true uncontrollability of the imagination. Without such investigative storytelling, it could be argued that McEwan's conveyance of the reality of the power of creativity would not have been so effectively highlighted without the integration of such minute details. Likewise, the novel's apt title, Atonement, is arrived at through an exploration of writing itself: from the point of view of Briony Tallis. Through the childlike innocence of a young girl and the seasoned woman she becomes, Briony realizes what it truly means to repent and makes amends. It is a difficult process, a lifelong struggle and one that is accomplished by finding oneself through the art of writing. An aspiring writer who seeks to atone for a misconstrued perception must ironically strive to find himself in the nature of writing itself. Throughout the pages of the novel,McEwan plays with irony in the writing as a central theme in the delivery of his plot, via his choice of narrative style. Rich, textured language decorates its chapters. Careful attention to sentence structure is clearly evident in McEwan's educated diction. Creating a stark contrast with the minimalist style popularized by novelists such as American writer Ernest Hemingway, McEwan tackles the description of this now national best-selling novel with verbose and generous language. While countless novelists attempt to execute this style of writing effectively, McEwan succeeds immensely in his mission by intertwining the relationship between writing as an important motif and a means of therapeutic self-exploration. In the film adaptation of the same title, director Joe Wright uses various locations in order to literally portray McEwan's description of the locations. Moving from Redcar seafront to the Great Scotland Yard as a backdrop to kaleidoscopic scenes, the film's cast uses each location as the most accurate representation of the novelist's original geographical ideology. Set at the Tallis family's opulent country estate during the sweltering summer of 1935, the first hour of Wright's film is cinematically dazzling. Visually enticing just as the novel's diction is intellectually engaging, screenwriter Christopher Hampton and director Joe Wright collaborate to present a plethora of dynamic characters. The Crew Tactics emphasizes young Robbie Turner's outsider status, cleverly depicting class separation as rigid and persistent. In this way, Wright emphasizes the detailed and faceted style of the novel – on the big screen. At the end of the film, Wright returns Atonement's attention to its main focus: words, more precisely, words with intention and force behind them. During the final scenes, an older Briony gives a television interview about her latest novel, the title of which reflects the McEwan novel mentioned here. Briony's character has limited screen time, a strategy that redirects the focus to the confabulation. The camera holds her wrinkled face in a long shot, and as the audience realizes that this television appearance is Briony's final interview for her latest novel, the bestselling novelist concisely shares key life lessons. His words are minimal, his sentences succinct. She reflects on life's tendency toward distress and its ramifications. Pausing, she continues by mentioning art's propensity to heal and provide relief. His revelations are shocking and brutally honest. Once again, the degree of complexity of multi-level language frames is at stake as Briony refuses to change the names of the characters in her novel. In contrast, in the 2005 American crime novel No Country for Old Men, McCarthy takes a minimalist approach via succinct sentences, brief paragraphs, and limited narration. McCarthy's presentation of the novel and commentary through explicit description effectively delivers his main motif of life and his propensity for abundance. McCarthy explores several key characters' different perspectives on how life should be lived through brief dialogue and direct conversations within his main cast. Forgoing the cumbersome effect of excessive imagery, detailed descriptions, and verbose vocabulary, McCarthy adapts the dialect of his characters, emphasizing his relationship with his fabricated dramatis characters. In stark contrast to McEwan's colorful novel, McCarthy's work is brutal, direct and jerky. Its sterile intensity creates a minimal backdrop to the diversity of its.