-
Essay / The social commentary of O Pioneers
Willa Cather's 1913 novel, O Pioneers! is very much a work of its time, providing social commentary on a number of important issues of the 19th to early 20th centuries. This commentary presents a variety of critical analytical frameworks: from the perspective of reform movements, immigrant culture, populism, and particularly women's rights. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get an original essayA possible analysis of O Pioneers! discusses the education and prison reform movements. Alexandra clearly values education: “[Alexandra] spent a whole day with a young farmer who was absent from school and who was experimenting with a new kind of clover hay” and wants “Emil to go to school” . Through Alexandra, Cather asks her reader to recognize the power of education as a tool to improve one's situation, thereby supporting the education reform movement. The novel then questions the treatment of the insane and calls for prison reform. Through Ivar, Cather communicates her distaste for insane asylums: “They built the asylum for different people,” Ivar tells Alexandra. And through Frank Shabata, Cather demonstrates the need for prison reform. After her visit to Frank, Alexandra feels disgusted by the prison: "She refused with horror the director's cordial invitation to 'visit the establishment'." Thus, Cather uses the thoughts and actions of her characters to support movements for prison and asylum reform. O Pioneers! can also be analyzed through its message on immigrant culture. Virtually all of the characters are immigrants and therefore experience conflict between their native culture and the norms of Nebraska. For example, the Bergsons' mother "has always missed the old country" and tries to hold on to some of her previous life, and Mrs. Lee looks forward to her visits with Alexandra to return to the "good old days." The novel illustrates the difficulty immigrants face in preserving a valuable original culture after moving to another continent. A third possible analysis critiques the novel through the prism of populism. In a rapidly transforming America, the populist movement sought to refute the image of the simple, stupid farmer and put power back in the hands of the people. O Pioneers! at its core is a novel about people who are far from reaching the highest ranks of society; Clearly, Cather found their stories worth telling. In her depiction of the hardships of pioneer agricultural life, Cather demonstrates the sophistication, power, and worldliness of the general public, thereby supporting the Populist movement. Finally, oh pioneers! can be analyzed for its messages about the women's rights movement. This work is unique in that it tells a pioneer story through the eyes of a woman, particularly because this woman powerfully challenges the gender stereotypes of the time. This was not a random choice: Cather's decision to center her novel on a strong female character makes overall sense because of the similarity between the reform and pioneering movements for women. Like the pioneers, members of the women's reform movement sought to push the boundaries and explore the margins of established society. Although pioneer women did this literally on the Great Plains, as the women's reform movement fought against societal rather than physical limitations, the inherent similarity is striking. By choosing a.