-
Essay / The Portrayal of the Nation in Lost Honor by Katharina Blum
Alexander Crummel once said that “the sense of responsibility that comes with power is the rarest of things” (n.d.). This is a concept explored in Heinrich Boll's 1975 novel The Lost Honor of Katharina Blum, in which Boll demonstrates the ways in which power was abused within the West German nation during the Cold War . It achieves this through its use of literary devices, such as symbolism, syntax, diction, metaphor, alliteration and dramatic irony, in revealing the merciless persecution of Katharina Blum at the hands of the police, the press and patriarchy after its fall. loves and spends a single night with the criminal Ludwig Gotten. The author highlights the corruption that can accompany power: the young woman's rights are violated by an unjust police force, her reputation is ruined by a capitalist press and her beauty is sexualized by the patriarchy. It is therefore to reveal the corrupt nation of West Germany that Boll follows Katharina through her trials and utter helplessness as she is tormented by the very structures meant to support her and the society around her. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why violent video games should not be banned"? Get the original essay In his account, Boll highlights the corruption of the West German police and contradicts the popular idea that they are simple protectors of the public. By exploring Katharina's harsh treatment by law enforcement while she is under investigation for helping Gotten escape, he is able to condemn the presence of a legal system, corrupt judiciary and government in West Germany that violates the rights of the weak and marginalized, rather than defending them. the powerless as they claim to do. This is clear from Katharina's damaged perception of her apartment, which she previously "loved so much", following the police's forced entry and search, a view which is evident when she "refused to return home, claiming that the events had ruined the apartment. for her once and for all", even specifying that she "preferred to wait in a cell". The invasion of her apartment, a symbol of her hard work, success and independence, represents the destruction of the life she has worked hard to build for herself at the hands of the police, backed by the power of law and under the guise of justice. . His preference for an uncomfortable and unpleasant cell rather than a hard-earned home underscores the extent of the harm caused by their intrusion into his residence and violation of his privacy, allowing Boll to criticize corrupt police use of its authority to undermine the dignity of the ordinary citizen and suggest their inability to protect the weak. Such ideas are further supported in the text, as the police force a helpless Katharina to undergo a humiliating interrogation, during which she is subjected to aggressive and vulgar questioning by the Chief Crime Commissioner, Erwin Biezmenne , who bluntly asks: “Did he fuck you?” The syntax, harsh terminology and personal nature of this question create a jarring and crude effect and reveal the disrespectful nature and callousness of the police force as they callously exercise their power. As the investigation continues, it appears that these harsh interrogations took place after the police discovered Gotten's location, as Biezmenne is criticized for leaving him "without any concern for almost forty -eight o'clock, when his presence at the Straubleder villa wasknown to the police". justice By exposing this corrupt abuse of power by West German police forces, Boll directly challenges the idealized image of the law and its enforcement as a symbol of justice, peace and protection. of the public.and positions the public to question the illusion of morality and justice that surrounds the country itself Boll presents the unethical and defamatory actions of the sensationalist press, motivated by its desire for accompanying profit. increased circulation, to criticize the capitalist ideologies that underpin Western society in Germany. By exploring the metaphorical death of Katharina's reputation at the hands of the News, the author is able to reveal the deceptive nature of "gutter journalism." to the extent that he abuses power to obtain monetary gain, proving that “when morality clashes with profit, profit rarely loses” (Crisholm, 1970). This is evident in their dramatic tracks of “Outlaw's Sweetheart” and “Murderer's Moll”. Here, the respective cliché and alliteration, as well as the evocative language chosen by the writer, reveal the News' attempts to present an innocent Katharina as complicit in Gotten's crimes, demonstrating their use of defamatory sensationalism to entice the public into purchasing their newspaper and thus strengthening their power over public perceptions. Although she is aware of the damaging impact these false articles would have on Katharina's reputation, the press's prioritization of profit over ethics leads them to continue to describe her as a "moll", which has damaging connotations of a manipulative and untrustworthy partner in crime. The use of dramatic irony and the structure of the text, as the audience knows she is innocent, allows Boll to criticize the media for the destruction of her name and reputation, and therefore of prevailing capitalism in West Germany which motivates them. This is further reinforced when it is revealed that "the information had transformed [Mr Blorna's] statement that Katharina was intelligent, calm and level-headed into 'icy and calculating'... and that she was 'quite capable of commit a crime.” ". This demonstrates how the media manipulated interviews to portray people in harmful ways to suit their own needs. Mr. Blorna's compliments to her character were twisted into cunning and misleading implications in order to present an incriminating portrayal of Katharina. By creating a guilty image of her through the use of diction, the media are able to sensationalize her story to increase circulation and maximize their own profit. The fact that this is achieved at the expense of Katharina's reputation allows Boll to question the belief that journalism is a symbol of truth, justice and integrity and to criticize the capitalism that drives the media to commit these unethical and cruel acts. Thus, by demonstrating the metaphorical murder of Katharina's reputation by the News, Boll is able to demonstrate the corruption within the West German media due to their capitalist nature. Boll deliberately connects Katharina's suffering to the patriarchy of West Germany in order to reveal its destructive consequences. caused by the male-dominated structure of the nation. He is able to criticize male supremacy in West Germany through the sexualized treatment of Katharina as a divorcee.