-
Essay / Impulse versus Logic in Thomas Mann's Death in Venice
In Thomas Mann's Death in Venice, Mann explores the struggle between impulse and logic through the baggage symbolism presented throughout. The baggage that Aschenbach clings to represents the domination of logic over his impulses and the effects of societal restrictions on his natural instincts. Aschenbach's evolving relationship with his baggage illustrates his natural progression away from the influences of social restrictions and his gradual adoption of innate drives. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get the original essay Mann demonstrates Aschenbach's gradual lifestyle change by initially affirming the values that baggage represents through associations, comparisons, and contrasts. The first example of baggage is introduced when Aschenbach arrives at his original vacation destination, a remote island, by a motorboat that has carried "him and his baggage into the misty dawn on the water" ( Mann, 15). Mann groups Aschenbach and his luggage as linked entities on the motorboat through the imagery of Aschenbach located near his luggage, but also through the form of the text by placing the two subjects in close proximity on the page, in order to demonstrate its attachment to luggage. Baggage also acts as an interference brought by civilization into the isolation and remoteness of the vacation island. The foggy surroundings and uncertainty about direction and destination demonstrate Aschenbach's myopia about his future and desires, and his inability to make the best decision. Mann then reinforces the fact that baggage is an extension of societal values by describing “those of the second”. social class” which was based on their “baggage bundles” and associated baggage with the norms of modern society (Mann, 16). As Aschenbach rides a gondola en route to the Hôtel des Bains, he not only admires the ship's "coffin black" seats, but also praises the gondola seat as "the softest...most relaxing seat on the world” (Mann, 20 years old). ). The connection between the black color of the coffin and relaxing qualities establishes death as a luxurious escape from the crushing stress of daily life and ultimate relaxation. Aschenbach's seat on the gondola is "opposite his luggage, which was carefully composed" in order to emphasize the contrast between the relief presented by death and the order, obligations and responsibilities represented by his luggage at the opposite of the spectrum (Mann, 20). After the bellboy brings the luggage to Aschenbach's hotel room, Aschenbach approaches a window and looks out to sea, hearing only the "rhythmic beating on the sand" (Mann, 24). The separation between the interior of the hotel room, where the luggage is located, and the outside world of nature parallels Aschenbach's struggle between the confinements imposed by societal norms and his natural instincts. Comparing and contrasting baggage with society's imagery, the ultimate relief from death, as well as the relaxation and freedom of nature, Aschenbach's baggage is the ultimate symbolism of the constraints established by societal values and of his overwhelming use of logic in his decision. As Aschenbach's trip to Venice progresses, the physical distance between Aschenbach and his luggage increases, and Aschenbach gradually confronts the values that the luggage represents, such as the societal restrictions placed on his life. Aschenbach's progress is announced when the gondolier informs him that he cannot bring luggage to the vaporetto and Aschenbach retorts: "I would perhapsreturn my luggage to storage. You will turn around” (Mann, 22 years old). The use of an exotic language for the name of the destination represents the cultural difference of a foreign country and its effect on distancing Aschenbach from its baggage, old customs, and burden of responsibility. Aschenbach's indecision over the placement of his luggage and repeated changes of direction highlight his confusion over whether he should consult his logic or his instincts in making a decision. En route to the Venetian hotel, Aschenbach ordered his “luggage [be] transported to the Hôtel des Bains” in a separate handcar as the first physical separation of his luggage in Venice (Mann, 23). Hôtel des Bains also translates to Hotel Bath, introducing images of Aschenbach using his stay in Venice to cleanse himself of his old inadequate lifestyles and move on again. However, Aschenbach does not comfortably accept the lack of luggage until he decides to leave Venice and the bellman warns him that the car is leaving soon, to which he passionately responds "well, then she might leave and take this trunk with her.” (Mann, 36 years old). Aschenbach's irritation with heavy time constraints has prevailed and revealed his preference for a leisurely lifestyle, and his lack of baggage only reinforces the new relaxation and frustration with obligations and constraints. As Aschenbach leaves the Hôtel des Bains with only his light carry-on luggage, Aschenbach laments. on the brevity of the trip and his meetings with Tadzio, and “in a rather unusual way for him, he said goodbye with his lips, he actually said it” when seeing Tadzio (Mann, 36). The repeated mention of time emphasizes Aschenbach's pull away from filling his time with responsibilities and obligations, and his quest for free time, where Aschenbach gains the freedom to become the sole influence of his actions. The more time Aschenbach spends in Venice, the more physical distance becomes established between Aschenbach and his luggage. His attitude toward his baggage also shifts from initial dependence to newfound, burden-free freedom. Aschenbach's transformation after his baggage leaves is highlighted by his spontaneity in saying goodbye to his unrequited obsession, Tadzio. The transformation endowed Aschenbach with aggression, the ability to act and act according to his inner desires without the constraints of logic and a society that condemns his obsession with Tadzio. Aschenbach demonstrates the completion of his transformation by revealing his homosexuality and his love for Tadzio, a feat impossible without using his new instincts, independence and aggression. The evolution of Aschenbach's relationship with his baggage ultimately allows Aschenbach to pursue his love for Tadzio without the constraints of society and demonstrates the random and uncontrollable nature of love, and illustrates the permanence of societal pressures and instincts innate natural qualities, as well as dependence on logic. ultimately an obstruction of human autonomy. Aschenbach's progress is proven by two parallel events that brought his transformation full circle. When Aschenbach first entered the Hôtel des Bains, he refrained from unpacking his luggage; an action that shows that logic is still the dominant reason in his head as well as his excessive reliance on caution. Also, by not unpacking, Aschenbach acknowledges the inevitable departure from Venice and a return to everyday life. During his second stay at the Hôtel des Bains, after returning his lost trunk, Aschenbach took full advantage of his second opportunity and showed his contempt for the constraints of his life by considering his debacle "such a happy coincidence... so the trunk lost was placed in his room, and he..