-
Essay / The Discipline of Love: A Critical Commentary on Sir Philip Sidney's "Astrophyl and Stella"
Sir Philip Sidney produced the first Elizabethan sonnet cycle "Astrophyl and Stella", which was published posthumously in 1591. The stylistic elements of the sonnet with which he introduces this cycle—including overlapping phrases, sensory details, imagery, and personification—culminate to describe a speaker's attempt to compose a sonnet for his beloved in the style of the traditional Petrarchan vanitas. Behind this image lies the speaker's confusion, rage, despair—and ultimately his reconciliation with his own writing process, which gives him a new understanding of what it means to write love poetry. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get the original essay The speaker of the poem begins by gently pronouncing his intention to convey his love through the raw but disciplined power of poetry: “ Love in truth and I want in verse to show my love” (line 1). Connected to a rigid metrical quatrain “abab” composed of iambic hexameters, it expects an easily readable progression: “Pleasure could make her read, reading could make her know” (line 3). In scansion, the speaker combines anaphora in syntax, through the rhetorical device of sentence overlap, and in diction, by selecting the word "could" to articulate each sentence together. Not only is this simple speech a concise and memorable summary of his inner thoughts, but it reflects a deliberate choice to present these thoughts in a highly structured pattern. Thus, his tone is contemplative for himself, inviting for the reader, and seductive for his idealized beloved. The overlapping phrases also set a pattern of thematic development later in the poem. Although the sentence overlap ends in the fourth line, the pattern of overlap continues in the developmental interaction of images and themes. The zeugma of the seventh line, “The leaves of others” (line seven) connects the image of leafing through scholarly or poetic articles and introduces more natural imagery for the next line. The “fresh and fruitful showers” of line eight add alliteration and direct sensory detail to this nature imagery. Finally, the image modulates into a personification of Nature in the tenth line as the mother of Invention. As the poem's images evolve, their thematic direction follows the same path. Line eight's metaphor of the speaker's "sunburnt brain" reveals a similar overlapping development toward personification. Simple devices evolve throughout the poem into a complex interplay of themes. By the second quatrain, three personifications are activated, each with a distinct agency. The nature, invention, and study of the tenth line take on roles of their own, not only beyond the direct control of the speaker, but actually subverting the rhetorical authority he exercised in the first quatrain. Their antics place the speaker in the position of an observer, trying to learn what he can but remaining temporarily passive. The reader, which usually occupies this position, is moved. More ironically, these are the same abstractions that were meant to guide a poet through the writing process. The eleventh line returns to the Zeugmatic double meaning of “others’ feet,” reflecting the thematic revolution of the sonnet. At this pivotal moment, the reader watches the speaker's voice waver. His simple, confident meditation turns into a dark amalgamation of thoughts. Confusion and frustration replace".